Close this search box.

Fielder's Choice

oob swirl graphic

Old Fashion Home-Made Ice Cream

Contact Info

Customer Reviews

Michael R

Ice Cream Lover’s Dream. This place is an ice cream lover’s delight. They have a gazillion flavors. My wife and I are in Old Orchard Beach,ME for the night and decided to go Fielder’s Choice based on the reviews from Yelp and Downeast Magazine. We jumped right in and each ordered The Dugout Floor. We got the small size called “Minor.” The large size is called “Major.” The Dugout Floor comes with hard serve ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, reeses peanut butter cups and whipped cream. We each got the chocolate Almond Joy ice cream (with pieces of the candy bar in the ice cream). All I can say is OMG!! These were huge. I can only imagine how big the Major size was. We should have just shared one. I ate about a quarter of mine and my wife ate even less of hers. There was so much good stuff. I wish there was one in North Carolina where we live. We would go all the time. My advice, GO HUNGRY!!

Rick M

Best Ice Cream in Old Orchard Beach. What can you say, if you’re in the Old Orchard Beach area, Fielder’s Choice has to be on your list! At times it’s crazy busy but that just gives you time to spend with each other.

Dean P

Best ice cream. We were in Orchard Beach for 3 nights and visited Fielder’s all 3 nights! The choices were awesome and everything that we tried was great. 11 of us traveling together could not stop talking about our ice cream experience at Fielder’s Choice!